top of page
  • Youtube
  • LinkedIn Social Icon
  • Twitter Social Icon
  • Instagram
  • Facebook Social Icon

Google Search Is Getting Worse. That’s the Point.

Writer: Twisha Prasad
Twisha Prasad
Jul 1
4 min read

“Google Search is getting worse.”

You’ve probably felt it.

Slower results. Longer answers. More effort.

At first glance, it looks like a regression.

It isn’t.

Google isn’t failing at search.

👉 It’s redefining what search is.

Part 1: The UX Regression Is Real

Let’s start with what’s undeniably true:

Search today feels worse than it used to.

Old Google:

  • ~300ms response time

  • 10 blue links

  • 2–3 seconds to decide

New AI-powered search:

  • 2–5 second latency

  • 200–300 word summaries

  • Requires reading, interpretation, and trust

The Hidden Shift: Recognition → Judgment

This is the most important UX shift.

Old search:👉 “Which link looks right?”

New search:👉 “Is this answer correct?”

That’s a fundamental change in cognitive load.

  • Recognition = fast, intuitive

  • Judgment = slow, effortful

Users have gone from:👉 scanningto👉 evaluating

The Cost of This Shift

Let’s quantify it:

  • Scanning results: ~2–3 seconds

  • Reading AI answer: ~45–90 seconds

That’s a 10–20x increase in attention cost.

On top of that, Google spent decades optimizing for speed.

Even a 100–500ms delay was known to impact engagement.

Now it’s accepting multi-second latency.

So yes—this is worse UX.

Which raises the real question:

👉 Why would Google choose this?

Part 2: You’re Judging the Wrong Metric

Most critiques stop at UX:

“It’s slower, so it’s worse.”

But Google is no longer optimizing for speed.

It’s optimizing for ownership of the answer layer.

The Real Shift: Navigation → Completion

Old Google:

  • Help users find information

  • Send them elsewhere

  • Win via clicks

New Google:

  • Deliver answers directly

  • Keep users inside

  • Win via completion

The Metric Rewrite

This is the shift most people miss.

Old metrics:

  • Click-through rate (CTR)

  • Time to first click

  • Query → click

New metrics:

  • Task completion rate

  • Zero-click satisfaction

  • Time within ecosystem

And Here’s the Data That Confirms It

Even before AI:

👉 Over 50–60% of searches already ended without a click

Featured snippets, knowledge panels, and ads had already reduced the need to leave Google.

AI didn’t start this trend.

👉 It completes it.

The Illusion That Just Broke

The “10 blue links” model didn’t die with AI.

It was already dying.

AI just removed the illusion that it still existed.

Part 3: The Strategic Tradeoff

This is a conscious decision.

Google is choosing:

👉 Worse micro-UXfor👉 Better macro-control

Why This Tradeoff Makes Sense

Because the real threat isn’t UX.

It’s disintermediation.

Part 4: The Existential Threat

For the first time, users don’t need links.

They can get answers directly.

That breaks Google’s core loop:

Query → Click → Ad

Now it becomes:

Query → Answer

No click.

No exit.

No traditional monetization path.

This Is Actually a Distribution War

Google isn’t just competing on quality.

It’s competing on:

👉 Where users start their query

Because whoever owns the starting point:

👉 Owns the user journey👉 Owns the monetization

Contrarian Take #1

Here’s the uncomfortable truth:

👉 AI search might feel worse for users—but better for Google’s business than ever before.

Because:

  • Fewer outbound clicks

  • More time inside Google

  • Greater control over the experience

The less users leave:

👉 The more powerful Google becomes

Part 5: This Pattern Has Happened Before

This isn’t new.

It just feels new.

Pattern: Local UX ↓, System Outcome ↑

  • Messier pages → higher conversion

  • Algorithmic feeds → higher retention

  • Autoplay → higher engagement

The Principle

Great product decisions often look like bad UX in isolation.

Because:

👉 UX is local👉 Strategy is systemic

Part 6: Where AI Search Actually Wins

To understand the shift, you have to be honest about where AI is better.

1. Synthesis

  • “Compare 5 insurance plans”

  • “Explain venture debt vs equity”

AI compresses:👉 10 tabs → 1 answer

2. Ambiguity

  • “Things to do in Bali”

  • “How to switch careers”

Search lists.

AI guides.

3. Multi-step Thinking

Planning, learning, decision-making.

This is where AI is 10x better.

The Real Insight

Not all queries are equal.

👉 The future of search is defined by complex, high-intent queries—not “weather today”

Part 7: Where It Still Fails

AI search is worse for:

  • Navigational queries

  • Known facts

  • High-trust domains

Because users don’t want synthesis.

👉 They want certainty.

Contrarian Take #2

The biggest risk isn’t bad UX.

👉 It’s loss of trust.

If users don’t trust the answer:

  • Speed doesn’t matter

  • Intelligence doesn’t matter

  • Distribution doesn’t matter

Trust is the real bottleneck.

Part 8: The Missing Layer

Google’s current flaw isn’t AI.

It’s routing.

Everything is being pushed into:

👉 “AI-first answers”

Instead of:

👉 “Right tool for the job”

Part 9: The Future Is Hybrid

The end state isn’t AI replacing search.

It’s intelligent orchestration.

The Winning System Will Route Like This:

Query Type

Experience

Simple

Links

Complex

AI

High trust

Verified sources

Exploratory

AI + links

The Real Product Problem

Not:

“How do we improve AI answers?”

But:

“When should AI be used at all?”

Part 10: The Deepest Shift

This is the part most people miss.

AI doesn’t just change UX.

👉 It changes where effort lives.

Old World

Effort = Finding information

New World

Effort = Verifying information

That’s a profound shift.

Because:

👉 Information is abundant👉 Trust is scarce

Contrarian Take #3

Google’s biggest competitor isn’t AI.

👉 It’s habit.

The real question isn’t:

“Are AI answers better?”

It’s:

👉 “Do users change where they start?”

Final Thought

Most people are asking:

“Why is Google making search worse?”

The better question is:

“What problem is Google solving now?”

And the answer is:

👉 Staying relevant in a world where answers don’t need links

One Line to Remember

Google didn’t break search.

👉 It broke the old definition of search.

Question to think about

If AI keeps improving:

Will users still prefer speed?

Or will they trade speed for completeness and certainty?

Because the answer to that question will define:

👉 The future of the internet

 
 
 

Comments


SIGN UP AND STAY UPDATED!

Thanks for submitting!

  • Grey Twitter Icon
  • Grey LinkedIn Icon
  • Grey Facebook Icon

© 2023 by Twisha Prasad

bottom of page